Sweet and savory variations on a familiar breakfast bread make for morning meals the whole family will enjoy.

Advertisement

There are three favorite "breads" served for breakfast in America: muffins, scones, and biscuits. (I am omitting sliced-bread toast, which is something very different.) Each of these has unique characteristics, of course, but defining exactly what they are is somewhat confusing. When I mentioned to a friend that I was writing my column on scones, he immediately asked, "What is the difference between scones and biscuits?"

The basic ingredients are essentially the same: flour, butter or shortening, milk or cream, leavening, and a bit of salt and possibly sugar. The method of preparation, too, is pretty similar: sift the dry ingredients, cut in the fat, and add the liquid. As with biscuits, the scone dough is rolled and cut into shapes. (Generally, muffins are made the way a cake is, by creaming butter and sugar, and then adding liquids and dry ingredients.)

I told my friend that I thought the difference was really just cultural and creative variation. Scones, which originated in Scotland, are associated with British high tea. They are leavened, fluffy or crumbly breads, once rather plain, that over time have been embellished with fruits and grains and even nuts and mashed potatoes. Scones have become a common and desirable breakfast bread that can be eaten simply with coffee and tea or topped with butter and jam for a bit more substance.

Biscuits, on the other hand, are American and have been made in pretty much the same way for centuries. Home cooks have very particular ways of dealing with the simple ingredients, and while some vary the ingredients -- substituting buttermilk for milk or cream, or butter for shortening or lard -- the result is usually a light, layered high-sided bread that can be used to soak up gravy or the soft yolks of poached eggs, or split open and eaten with butter and jam.

We decided for this column to focus on the different techniques for making scones. Rolled and cut, or patted into rounds, squares, or triangles, scones now are made in an interesting array of flavors. Home bakers are always adding something new to the dough -- chocolate chips, raspberries, pureed pumpkin, dates, dried cranberries or sour cherries, and even cheese -- to entice the family.

Whether you eat flaky scones for breakfast or serve them as a lovely after-school snack, the following recipes are worthy, I think, of inclusion in your baking repertoire.

Recipes

3 Tips for Delicious Scones

No matter which recipe you decide to try, follow these tips for professional results.

Folding: For this process, you fold the dough as you would a letter, and then roll it out to distribute the pieces of butter through- out the layers of dough. The butter pieces form pockets of steam in the oven and give the scones their light and flaky texture. See our Scones 101 guide for a step-by-step how-to.

Sugaring: Sprinkling on sugar adds an extra element of sweetness and crunch. You can use one of the wet ingredients from your recipe -- egg, egg white, buttermilk, cream -- to adhere the sugar. Try granulated, sanding, and raw sugar for different textures and finishes.

Cutting: This technique can be used for almost any scone. Form a rectangle, and use a long chef's knife to cut the dough into squares. It's quick, requires no special cutters, and leaves no waste behind. There's no rerolling, which can diminish the texture of a scone. Remember to dust your knife with a little flour.

Honoring a Classic

A freshly baked rich cream scone served with butter, jam, and Devonshire cream conjures up afternoon teatime in a great English hotel.

Time-Saving Tip

I often use a food processor to cut the cold butter into dry ingredients; it works fabulously. This technique was used for the candied orange and golden raisin scones.

Healthier Take

Apple and oat scones feature fresh fruit and buttermilk instead of cream. They are high in fiber, too.

Comments (4)

Anonymous
April 30, 2018
I was having the scone v. biscuit debate with an English friend and decided to google it in the hope of finding confirmation of my position. (Fiona claims that the biscuit she was served in NYC with fried chicken was actually a scone.) I figured your article would be a good place to begin, but you lost me at "high tea," since you obviously are laboring under the American confusion of "afternoon tea" with "high tea" (the latter actually being a working class supper, which was served at a high - think kitchen or dining room - table, whereas afternoon tea was served at low tables - think coffee table or cocktail table - in a room with couches and upholstered chairs, including hotel lobbies. Guess I'll seek wisdom elsewhere.
Anonymous
October 31, 2017
I have to agree with jgreilly. A scone is not defined by its filling or additions to the dough. In fact the plain scone is the most traditional. It's served with cream, butter and jam or preserves (jelly in America). The pastry should melt in the mouth. Firstly a scone is not a "bread" it's a tea pastry. A biscuit is a bread. The glutens in the dough for scones are not brought out so it has no stretch at all, it is never repeatedly rolled out in layers or worked to that extent. There is also a long tradition of using buttermilk in scones as an alternative to full milk, plus an egg or two for enrichment. Sugar, is also added, preferably castor sugar because you absolutely don't want anything grainy like ordinary sugar in there. Rich butter is used and never plain lard. A scone is basically a very short dough tea pastery. The shape is generally always round as that gives you the best rise. Rise they must, you should be able to just break them in two with your hands. The texture of a scone is very different to any of the bready biscuits I've ever tasted. However recently I have been noticing that Americans are using the same technique to make biscuits as are traditionally use to make scones so the differences between the two are becoming confused. However generaly the bread biscuits I've eaten in America have always been just that, bread. Although yeast is not used they dough is mostly worked or folded repeatedly and rolled until there is a good amount of gluten going on. So you get bready flakes as it were. This you would never ever find in a scone, it should be extremely light, just moist and just crumbly enough not to fall apart. A perfectly short dough without layers as such. Lightly crisp on the outside and soft and steamy on the inside. Hope that helps a bit.
Anonymous
August 30, 2016
Using shortening gives the scones a "bite" or crispness that butter does not.
Anonymous
July 31, 2016
There are more significant differences between scones and biscuits. Scones typically have eggs in them and biscuits do not. Scones tend to be a little denser, drier, and not as flaky. Just adding oats, fruit, herbs or anything else to a biscuit dough and cutting them in triangles does not make them a scone. Delicious nonetheless but not a scone!