A Playful Summer Wedding on Shelter Island, New York

Photo: Amaranth Photography

Rachel and Andrew's big day was a carefree summer affair detailed with vintage touches, bright floral arrangements, and live bluegrass music.

01 of 19

Rachel and Andrew

Amaranth Photography

Rachel and Andrew found love in Brooklyn, New York, where the East Coasters' love flourished over time and led a romantic marriage proposal.The pair's love of New York's natural beauty inspired them to pick a venue on Shelter Island for their colorful summer celebration.

On July 12, 2014, Rachel and Andrew said their "I do's" before 175 of their closest friends and family in a garden party at Sylvester Manor. The expansive property's secret gardens, scenic views, and sentimental value to the couple, made for an enchanting and vibrant event canvas. The duo incorporated creative and artistic elements into the day, such as a custom wreath symbol and the musical talents of their friends from Australia and Brooklyn.

02 of 19

The Stationery

Amaranth Photography

Rachel and Andrew collaborated with their friend and illustrator, Edwina White, to create the custom stationery suite. Edwina created a collaged wreath image, which was paired with calligraphy and nautical code flag imagery to round out the design.

03 of 19

The Style

Amaranth Photography

Rachel and Andrew were a comfy-cool bride and groom—with Rachel rocking her self-made backless gown and delicate silver bracelets from the groom himself, and Andrew in a dark blue suit and tie.

Being a costume designer, Rachel couldn't resist the opportunity to create her own dress. "I made it from a ramshackle Edwardian tea dress and contemporized it by layering it with chiffon and grossgrain ribbon," says Rachel.

04 of 19

The Rings

Amaranth Photography

The duo's wedding bands are from different vendors—Rachel's from Cathy Waterman, and Andrew's from Bittersweets.

05 of 19

Bridal Bouquet

Amaranth Photography

Rachel told her florist, Peartree Flowers, to use "whatever looked the most beautiful in the flower market that day." The end result was a lush bouquet of mostly pink and red blooms—including ranunculus, roses, lisianthus, astilbe, and peonies.

06 of 19

The Flower Girls

Amaranth Photography

The sweet flower girls, in white eyelet dresses from Gap, were the daughters of a lifelong friend of the groom, who also served as the officiant at the ceremony.

07 of 19

The Groomsmen

Amaranth Photography

Andrew's close friends wore either a dark navy or gray suit with a white shirt and their own tie, making for a fun, mismatched group of groomsmen.

08 of 19

The Bridesmaids

Amaranth Photography

"I asked my bridesmaids to wear long floral dresses. I didn't give them any other guidelines beyond wanting them to find a dress that they would wear many times over," explains the bride.

09 of 19

Couple's Portraits

Amaranth Photography

Rachel and Andrew wanted to enjoy as much time as possible with their friends and family and opted for a portrait session prior to the ceremony.

Amaranth Wedding Photography photographed the couple in various spots on Sylvester Manor's lush property.

10 of 19

The Procession

Amaranth Photography

Rachel's father escorted her down the aisle to Bach's "Cello Suites No.1" during the garden ceremony.

11 of 19

The Vows

Amaranth Photography

"We stuck with traditional vows; it's nice to think of the same vows repeated over many generations," says Rachel. The ceremony readings included excerpts chosen from Letters to a Young Poet by Rainer Maria Rilke, and Freedom by Jonathan Franzen.

12 of 19

The Seating Chart

Amaranth Photography

Bethany Siekmeier wrote the seating chart on a giant chalkboard, which was set out on the lawn at the cocktail hour.

13 of 19

The Menu

Amaranth Photography

The organic dinner menu was written on the other side of the chalkboard seating chart. Both sides of the display included a special detail from the customized invitations—the colorful, collaged wreath.

14 of 19

The Reception

Amaranth Photography

The reception was held under a large sailcloth tent filled with both rectangular and square tables set with a plethora of votives, floral arrangements, and vintage white lace table clothes that Rachel and her mom collected six months leading up to the big day.

15 of 19

The Centerpieces

Amaranth Photography

Long tables boasted petite arrangements of pink blooms created by Peartree Flowers.

16 of 19

Table Numbers

Amaranth Photography

Table numbers incorporated the wreath created by the couple and Edwina White.

17 of 19

First Dance

Amaranth Photography

The duo shared their first dance to Neil Young's "Harvest Moon," ironically, under a full moonlit sky.

18 of 19

Into the Night

Amaranth Photography

The night was topped off with a surprise belated Fourth of July firework show on the horizon while the celebration and dancing continued on late into the night.

19 of 19


Amaranth Photography

Photography: Amaranth Wedding Photography

Location and Catering: Sylvester Manor

Flowers: Peartree flowers

Stationery: Edwina White

Calligraphy: Bethany Siekmeier

Music: Baby Copperhead; Appleonia; DJ Jimmy Wilson

Rentals: Party Rentals Ltd.; Sperry Tents

Makeup: Mandy Bisesti

Wedding Bands: Cathy Waterman; Bittersweets

Flower Girl Dresses: Gap

Was this page helpful?
Related Articles