Reviews (49)

40 Ratings

5 star values: 16
4 star values: 7
3 star values: 6
2 star values: 7
1 star values: 4

Anonymous

11/16/2017

For some folks, adding even small amounts of citrus rind or zest overwhelms everything else making the taste bitter. consider leaving it out.

Anonymous

11/21/2011

I love this recipe but I cook the filling before I put it in the crust. This gets rid of the runny filling, intensifies the flavors and stops the a pocket of air that forms between the apples and the crust as the apples cook down. I basically cooked it on medium low until the apples are just starting to soften and the liquid gets syrupy.

Anonymous

11/18/2010

Our favorite apple pie. We have been making this for years.

Anonymous

11/25/2008

My husband and I made this pie together and entered it in a pie contest at church. We took first prize! Yummy!!

Anonymous

07/11/2008

evaball, If you think your crust might burn before your pie is done, or if you know your oven is wacky, I recommend loosely placing some aluminum foil, shiniest side up, over your pie and crimping lightly around your edges, this will keep a lot of the heat off the top, but still cook the pie; (just DON'T make the foil airtight!) Then remove the foil with enough time, at the end of the baking process, for it to brown.

Anonymous

07/11/2008

Beurre729: You do not have to "blind bake" a pie crust for Apply Pie (that means baking the bottom crust with no pie in it before you actually bake the pie).

Anonymous

07/11/2008

hollygb22, It's a shame your pie didn't turn out. Ffor some reason, they left out of the directions that you should "dock" your pie before baking, which means you prick the bottom of the unbaked pie crust with a fork, and also leave some kind of opening in the top crust for steam to vent out. This pie crust is all overlapping disks so the steam can not get out (which is what made your crust soggy, and your pie so soupy) When I make this pie, I am going to prick some of the disks with a fork

Anonymous

05/28/2008

i wasnt a huge fan of this pie. I didn't particularly like the mix of spices. The filling was very liquidy and the bottom crust soggy. Next time (although the recipe doesn't call for it) I will bake the bottom crust first. I added 15 minutes to the baking time and had to tent with foil maybe 30 min. in to avoid a burnt top crust.

Anonymous

04/30/2008

Like gr8danegirl this was my first pie ever, and I made sure to do everything from scratch so it would taste the way it was supposed to- no one could believe it was my first pie! I did add some different species of apple, however, because being locked up in a cabin in the middle of the backcountry kind of limits you to what you already have. Still a hit. :)

Anonymous

03/22/2008

Making this pie for the third time this Easter. I know apple isn't what folks think of as spring or Easter, but the pie is so showy and pretty. I received so many compliments when I made it for Thanksgiving and Christmas parties that I will totally make it a keeper. The round cut-outs as the top crust are just so great! I use different cutters and shapes--leaves, flowers etc. Instead of sanding sugar, I used raw sugar---great amber shiney topper. Love this recipe!!!!!!

Anonymous

03/18/2008

This was the first pie I had ever made, in my entire life! I was making it to take to a family get-together. Neddless to say, I was rather nerveous of the outcome, so, I followed the recipe as if my life depended on it. Amazingly, it was fantastic. No one believed this was my first pie. My pie and I caused quite a sensation.

Anonymous

03/18/2008

Anonymous

12/28/2007

To Shutsy: All-purpose flour would be similar to your plain flour - DEFINIITELY NOT self-rising flour!

Anonymous

12/27/2007

I need some help. Would like to make this, could someone please tell me what All-purpose flour is. We have either Plain or Self-Raising Flour.

Anonymous

12/22/2007

if the top browns to quickly, should i bake the pie for a while and then add the top towards the end of the baking process? i have never made a pie before... this will be my first one.

Anonymous

12/03/2007

Hi all, I made this pie for Thanksgiving and used just about 5 pounds of apples using a mixtures of all my favorite apples. The pie came out so beautifully. I used sanding sugar all over the top. We didn't want to cut into it because it was so pretty. I followed the recipe exactly except I cut all of my apples about the same size. I think Martha cuts some thicker than others. Mine were all about 1/4 of an inch thick. It's a wonderful pie.

Anonymous

11/27/2007

I made this pie for thanksgiving and everyone loved it, although I did have to make a few adjustments. First I used frozen organic piecrusts as a shortcut, and tented the pie 15 min into baking because the crust became too brown. After it was finished I had to drain the pie because there was not enough flour in the apple mixture. The second pie I made I drained first, then baked it at 350 F for 100 min and it came out much better

Anonymous

11/27/2007

A stick of butter is 1/4 pound. You get 4 sticks in a one pound butter box. it is also 8 tablespoons. Hope this helps :) ---Kathy

Anonymous

11/24/2007

Please, somebody, what does a "stick" of butter weigh? Either metric or US I can convert from either, but a "stick" - please help.

Anonymous

11/23/2007

I made this pie yesterday and it was delicious! Everyone loved it! I did alter the recipe a little based on everyone's comments. I used 4 pounds of apples instead of 5, and I used a mix of apples (Baerburn, Fuji, Granny Smith and Golden, mostly Golden). I added a pinch more of flour so my filling was not 'liquidy'. I did have to cover the crust with aluminum foil rather quickly, especially because the top of it was getting dark quick. I will definitely make it again!

Anonymous

11/21/2007

I made this pie yesterday and it came out great! I didn't have fluted cutters so I used the smallest size round biscuit cutters with great results. mpalumbosu, click on the recipe for Pate Brisee and that's the recipe for the top and bottom crust. It was really easy to make, but chill it well before rolling for best results. This whole pie came out fantastic, it tastes great and looks very impressive. The top crust browned very quickly, I had to tent it with foil after only 25 minutes.

Anonymous

11/21/2007

I am a bit confused this is for the top of the pie alone right? I still have to get the directions for the bottom part.

Anonymous

11/21/2007

Lessons learned (i made this pie as a trial run last night): 1) Frozen butter is different than cold butter 2) You'll definitely need the aluminum foil to keep crust from burning 3) 5 lbs of apples is a LOT, i think I'm going to use 2.5-3lbs next time 4) Granny smith apples plus lemon zest and juice make this pie pretty tart. Tweak accordingly. I'm probably going to use less lemon zest and different apples. 5) All in all- Great pie.

Anonymous

11/20/2007

To BrennaWiles: I saw Martha do this pie on her show, and the 1/4 cup of flour that goes into the filling (she said) is supposed to soak up all the juices that the apples extract when baking, so maybe you can try adding more flour so that your filling is less 'liquidy'. I think I am going to try to make this pie as well...let me know if this helps.

Anonymous

11/19/2007

This pie looks amazing! Thanks for all the tips, cant wait to eat at Thanksgiving.

Anonymous

11/19/2007

Hi Beurre 729, Both crusts of a a fruit pie are baked after filled and topped. Enjoy!

Anonymous

11/19/2007

I am making this pie for thanksgiving , ive never made a baked pie before

Anonymous

11/18/2007

I am making this pie for Thanksgiving

Anonymous

11/18/2007

Do I pre-bake the pie crust? It doesn't say. Also, didn't realize you had to "click" on the pie crust to get recipe. "Pate Brisee"

Anonymous

11/16/2007

Am i supposed to bake the crust of the pie first before placing the filling in the crust like the bottom comment says? Can please someone help me because i am new at this and on the instructions it doesnt say to bake the crust first.

Anonymous

11/16/2007

I tried this recipe over the weekend and made a rookie mistake. I forgot to bake the pie crust before adding my filling. Unfortunately it was a tad bit soft. Also, I found my filling to be too "liquidy". It didn't stay in its nice pie piece shape like it was supposed to. It tasted wonderful, but I would like to imporve the next time I make it, any suggestions?

Anonymous

11/15/2007

Try cooksdream.com for the cutters.

Anonymous

11/15/2007

This pie took me much longer to make than I had expected. A lot of juices spilled over in my oven. Putting the tray below saved a lot of clean up. Piie is beautiful. Looks just like the one on the video. Typed recipe calls for egg wash (l egg yolk and cream). On the show (video) egg wash is 1 egg yolk and water. I used 1 yolk and 1 T water as in the video. I suppose either would be fine. Love this pie!!!!

Anonymous

11/15/2007

anyone know where I can get a fluted round cutter?

Anonymous

11/15/2007

does anyone know if I can use other varieties or apples other than Granny Smith? thanks

Anonymous

11/14/2007

I wondered the same thing about the size of this pie, so I watched the posted video from the show that day. At the beginning Martha says they are using 4lbs of apples so the 5 called for in this recipe should be plenty.

Anonymous

11/14/2007

I, too want to make the extra tall pie that Martha made with Rachel Weitsz...Is this the recipe, or is it the Mile HIgh Pie with the fancy crust?. I need to make mine for our office Thanksgiving lunch this Friday...would like to shop tonight...Thank you so much....Debbie Douglas, Corpus Christi, Tx.

Anonymous

11/14/2007

I watched you make this pie on Monday, November 12. My question is: The picture of this pie is not the very high (or mile high) applie pie with the pate brisee circles built up on top of the mound of apples. Will this pie turn out like the one on your show since it calls for 5 lbs. of apples? I'd love to know since I plan to make this pie for Thanksgiving. By the way, I love your show and everything you create! Diane Wood - Griffin, Georgia (dianetw)

Anonymous

11/13/2007

If you click on "Pate Brisee" under the ingredients list above, it will take you to the recipe for the crust.

Anonymous

11/13/2007

I also would like the "Best Pie Crust" recipe as you have so many to choose from. Have not made pies for a few years, but I will be making this one. Also would like to know the best apples to use. Await your answer. Do I wait to hear from other members or does Martha's team email me? I just started this after seeing the pie on TV today. Thank you.

Anonymous

11/13/2007

Where can I find the recipe for Martha's pie crust to this recipe? She referred to it as the best pie crust recipe..... Happy Thanksgiving to Martha

Anonymous

11/13/2007

Just watched on my DVR -- they were Granny Smith.

Anonymous

11/13/2007

Martha used a mixture of apples this morning on the show. What were they, other than the granny smith?

Anonymous

11/13/2007

click on Pate Brisee for the pie crust recipe

Anonymous

11/13/2007

Can you mix granny smith and red apples? I don't know if I would like all tart apples, or does the sugar added compensate for that? Also, would the bake time change if I used an apple slicer (making thinner spiral slices instead of big wedges)?

Anonymous

11/13/2007

I am going to make this apple pie and report back what it tastes like and if I made it correctly when I make it.

Anonymous

11/13/2007

What is the ingredients for the pie crust??

Anonymous

11/13/2007

The pie Martha made on tv this morning was alot bigger. Is this the same recipe?

Anonymous

11/13/2007

What are the ingredients for the pie dough?

More Reviews

Homeschool with Martha

Sensory Crafts and Activities for Kids

These Recipes All Start with a Can of Beans

Spiced Apple Pie with Fluted Round Cutouts

Ingredients

Directions

Reviews (49)

All Reviews for Spiced Apple Pie with Fluted Round Cutouts

Account

More

Spiced Apple Pie with Fluted Round Cutouts

Ingredients

Directions

Reviews (49)

All Reviews for Spiced Apple Pie with Fluted Round Cutouts