Candy-Corn Sugar Cookies

224 Ratings
  • 5 48
  • 4 57
  • 3 78
  • 2 34
  • 1 7

These petite fall treats will charm all but the grumpiest ghouls. Simple sugar cookies are garnished with candy corn pieces for a sweet fall treat.

Everyday Food, October 2004

Gallery

Recipe Summary

prep:
15 mins
total:
30 mins
Yield:
Makes about 36
Advertisement

Ingredients

Directions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Place butter and sugar in a medium bowl; beat with a wooden spoon until combined. Beat in egg yolk, vanilla, baking powder, and salt. Add flour, and mix until a dough forms.

    Advertisement

  • Scoop out level teaspoons of dough, and roll into balls (chill dough briefly if it becomes too soft to handle). Place balls on baking sheets, 2 inches apart.

  • Bake, rotating sheets halfway through, until edges are firm and cookies are dry to the touch (do not let cookies color), 10 to 12 minutes.

  • Remove from oven; gently press a candy corn into center of each cookie (surface of cookies may crack slightly). Cool on sheets 1 minute; transfer to a rack to cool completely.

Cook's Notes

Right after removing the cookies from the oven, be sure to press in the candies. Scoop out all of the dough into level teaspoons (onto a plate of wax paper) before rolling them into balls.

Variations

Chocolate Variation: Reduce the amount of flour given in the recipe to 1/2 cup. Add 1/4 cup unsweetened cocoa powder along with the flour in step 1, and proceed.

Advertisement

Reviews (35)

224 Ratings
  • 5 48
  • 4 57
  • 3 78
  • 2 34
  • 1 7
Martha Stewart Member
10/14/2013
Normally, I swear by Living recipes, but this is not a good one. I am a regular and avid baker and wanted to make these for my daughter's preschool bake sale. I could tell something was off before they went in the oven-the dough was extremely dry. They didn't bake down into rounds and when we tried to press the candy corn in the whole cookie fell apart. Will not make again. We made the chocolate version and doubled the recipe. It felt like the butter measure was off or a liquid element missing.
Martha Stewart Member
10/31/2011
I may use this recipe, but I may just end up using my sugar cookie recipe and add cocoa to half of it. That way I have a bigger batch.
Martha Stewart Member
10/23/2011
I made both the chocolate and the plain cookies. I followed the recipe exactly, and they turned out great. I also used various types of candy toppings (e.g. sprinkles, pumpkin pie Hershey's Kisses, M&M's, Reece's Pieces), and I even frosted some with orange buttercream frosting. The recipe is easily modifiable. Make sure to use a teaspoon to form the dough balls (and to chill before baking) in order to make the cookies bite sized. A wonderful, seasonal treat!!! Highly recommended.
Advertisement
Martha Stewart Member
10/17/2011
I made these for my daughter's pre-school class and doubled the recipe, which made 26 regular size cookies. I would suggest doubling if you want to make them a bit bigger and have a few more cookies. They turned out great.
Martha Stewart Member
11/01/2010
I made these with my grandsons and they enjoyed them. I'm not sure why the dry ingredients with the wet instead of mixing them with the flour. I needed the whole egg as there wasn't enough moisture in the batter. But, they were good and soft like my hubby likes them and my grandsons. I'm a crispy cookie person myself.
Martha Stewart Member
10/24/2010
These cookies were delicious. I measured the teaspoonfuls and got 16 cookies with about half the dough. My 2 year old helped me make them and she loved them. Will make these every Halloween and perhaps for other holidays with a different center. It's a keeper!
Advertisement
Martha Stewart Member
10/13/2010
I made the chocolate cookies and they were fabulous! I added 1/4 tsp. of cinnamon for a little extra something. They were a big hit. Hubby took a batch with him for the people at his office. They devoured them and then requested more so I made another batch. Since the cookies are so small I recommend at least doubling the recipe. Happy baking! :)
Martha Stewart Member
10/13/2009
Here's a link to a very easy candy corn cookie: http://www.bettycrocker.com/recipes.aspx/candy-corn-cookies?WT.mc_id=paid_search_200100_636117
Martha Stewart Member
12/15/2008
I have made these several times. I always measure the dough using a T. The cookies are tiny - just a bit bigger than the candy corn. I like to add almond extract (1/4 t. ) instead of vanilla. The chocolate ones are equally delicious. Perfect for Halloween or Thanksgiving. My kids LOVE them!
Martha Stewart Member
11/17/2008
a surprisingly harmonious combination... it is very sweet, don't get me wrong, but it definitely has that nostalgic baking-and-frosting-Pillsbury-sugar-cookies at a kid's holiday party quality that is almost worth the sugar shock. I got 40 cookies and they were the size shown in the picture. Quick and easy enough to be worth it for pleasing a crowd (especially a crowd of kids or even easy going adults, just be sure to pass some good coffee...).
Martha Stewart Member
10/30/2008
I made the recipe verbatim and it came out to 36 cookies and the candy corn fit on perfectly. My son Loves these cookies and it only took half an hour start to finish.
Martha Stewart Member
10/30/2008
How much cocoa powder would I need to add to make the chocolate ones? And, if adding cocoa powder, should I use a whole egg, rather than just the egg white?
Martha Stewart Member
10/29/2008
I used a #100 disher to portion out the dough (instead of rolling it in balls) and I got 24 - barely! They did spread out to look bigger than those pictured, however. They are tasty, but nothing special. I served these at a halloween party and this was the only item I served that not one person commented on (not even to say they were cute!). So I think I will stick with my sugar cookie recipes that get a better reaction.
Martha Stewart Member
10/18/2008
If you read the instructions, it says to measure out in leveled teaspoons. I did this and got just short of 36 cookies. I think the people who got fewer might have missed that instruction. These are small bite sized cookies, but they're very yummy. Great recipe.
Martha Stewart Member
10/17/2008
This recipe was easy, yet delicious! Thanks Martha! This one is a keeper!
Martha Stewart Member
10/15/2008
I think this cookie was really tasty and easy to make, but I only got 12 cookies out of the recpie. And after looking at otehr comments seems like others had the same issue....I think this might be a typo
Martha Stewart Member
10/14/2008
Mixed up a double recipe for a charity bake sale ... what a surprise to see that the double recipe yielded only 2 dozen 2" cookies! Off to my recipe box to see what else I can shake up before going to bed ... big disappointment but a cute cookie. slk
Martha Stewart Member
10/14/2008
I agree. This recipe makes 12 normal size cookies....if you were to make the 36 teaspoon size cookies, the candy corn is bigger than the cookie!
Martha Stewart Member
10/12/2008
This recipe made about 12 cookies. I cannot imagine why it says 36; they would have to be dime-sized for this to be true!
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
these are great for teachers if you have kids and they are great for adult/ kid partys
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
these are great for teachers if you have kids and they are great for adult/ kid partys
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
these are great for teachers if you have kids and they are great for adult/ kid partys
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
I found the dough to be very crumbly, but my hands warmed it when I rolled it into balls. No way I could roll the tsp size - I had to do a tablespoon and they look just like the picture. Too sweet for my taste, but kids do love them. It made 17 for me.
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
I found the dough to be very crumbly, but my hands warmed it when I rolled it into balls. No way I could roll the tsp size - I had to do a tablespoon and they look just like the picture. Too sweet for my taste, but kids do love them. It made 17 for me.
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
I found the dough to be very crumbly, but my hands warmed it when I rolled it into balls. No way I could roll the tsp size - I had to do a tablespoon and they look just like the picture. Too sweet for my taste, but kids do love them. It made 17 for me.
Martha Stewart Member
10/09/2008
I just made these and they are so yummy! Almost impossible not to continuously munch on! Yum Yum! The candy really adds a special touch!!
Martha Stewart Member
10/08/2008
These look delicious one more for my halloween baking !!!
Martha Stewart Member
10/07/2008
Oh I would love to see your results ! What a cute idea !
Martha Stewart Member
10/07/2008
These look good, but they gave me another idea entirely. Making sugar cookies that look like candy corn. I will be doing this over the weekend and will take a photo and post it to my profile. The idea is really a selfish one for me. My husband and daughter like candy corn but I don't! But the idea of a cute seasonal theme cookie is great. Wish me luck!
Martha Stewart Member
10/07/2008
If you have too dry a dough, try adding a whole egg or a tablespoon or two of milk. If one is to put three candy corns on 36 cookies, then you will need 108 candy corns. if making chocolate flavored cookies you do need a bit more liquid as the cocoa powder will be a bit dryer. I am a real cookie nut and am constantly experimenting with new recipes. My kitchen is my laboratory.
Martha Stewart Member
10/07/2008
If you have too dry a dough, try adding a whole egg or a tablespoon or two of milk. If one is to put three candy corns on 36 cookies, then you will need 108 candy corns. if making chocolate flavored cookies you do need a bit more liquid as the cocoa powder will be a bit dryer. I am a real cookie nut and am constantly experimenting with new recipes. My kitchen is my laboratory.
Martha Stewart Member
10/07/2008
I made these and used candy corn kisses. They were delicious.
Martha Stewart Member
10/07/2008
I made these and used candy corn kisses. They were delicious.
Martha Stewart Member
09/25/2008
did anyone else have a problem with the consistency of the dough? mine turned out to be very powdery, almost like there wasn't enough liquid added to it.
Martha Stewart Member
09/16/2008
These cookies are realy delicious and great for Halloween!!
Load More Reviews
© Copyright 2023 Martha Stewart. All rights reserved. Printed from https://www.marthastewart.com 01/29/2023