Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookies
These cookies are crispy at the edges, chewy in the center, and loaded with 2 kinds of chocolate. Feel free to add 2 cups chopped walnuts or pecans to the dough.
Everyday Food, October 2009
396 Ratings
- 5 star values: 112
- 4 star values: 110
- 3 star values: 101
- 2 star values: 49
- 1 star values: 24
undefined Member
Rating: 5.0 stars
I am 68 years old and these are the BEST choc chip cookies I have ever made! I used a melon ball scoop and the cookies did NOT flatten out, but made 6 1/2 dozen, almost 2 inch diameter, delightful cookies! Pre formed cookie dough speeds chilling. Used 2 cups of chopped pecans. Perfect!
undefined Member
Rating: 5.0 stars
I am 68 years old and these are the BEST choc chip cookies I have ever made! I used a melon ball scoop and the cookies did NOT flatten out, but made 6 1/2 dozen, almost 2 inch diameter, delightful cookies! Pre formed cookie dough speeds chilling. Used 2 cups of chopped pecans. Perfect!
undefined Member
Rating: 5.0 stars
I am a first time user of the recipe. My daughter and I made them without a beater. And we did have to cut it in half and leave it a minute longer in the oven but they turned out great. Crisp outer shell and soft on the inside. I recommend this one. Delicious! 5 stars.
Advertisement
undefined Member
Rating: 5.0 stars
A friend and I were having to make cookies for a Christmas party this week and I ran across this recipe and OH MY GOODNESS what a good choice that was!! The both of us fell in love with this recipe, the texture by far was the best I have ever had in a chocolate chip cookie. Every little thing about it was perfect.
undefined Member
Rating: 5 stars
They did not stay puffed. Flattened right out. Still taste good though.
undefined Member
Rating: 2 stars
Did anyone else's cookies come out very brown and greasy? Not to mention flat. I used the exact ingredients and followed the recipe exactly as written. When you pick up these cookies, they leave a greasy film on your fingers. And my cookies do not look like the picture. I suspect all the brown sugar turns them brown. I won't be making these again. There are too many other chocolate chip recipes out there.
Advertisement
undefined Member
Rating: 5 stars
The only addition I made was adding 1 cup of crushed toffee.
undefined Member
Rating: 5 stars
These are amazing cookies! I don’t understand the reviews giving this recipe less than 5 stars. This is my go to recipe for chocolate chip cookies and j get asked for the recipe every time I make them! You have to follow the instructions placing them in the fridge first before baking but other than that they are easy. Sometimes I dividend the recipe I’m half, because it is a big batch, and sometimes I make the full batch and freeze the cookie balls using my foodsavwr. I defrost to a cool temp and bake them accordingly. Come out almost as good as the freshly made dough.
undefined Member
Rating: 5 stars
We loved this recipe, but I overlooked one batch and undercooked another...but the others were just perfect! Making them again tonight!
undefined Member
Rating: 5 stars
Delicious! I was recommended this recipe by my best friend. It never disappoints. The added salt makes this recipe. It really compliments the sweetness. I like to freeze mine briefly before baking to prevent over spreading. Anyone that dislikes this recipe either dislikes salt and/or cannot bake.
undefined Member
Rating: 5 stars
A friend gave me this recipe 7 years ago, and now they are the only cookies I make! For dinner parties, everyone asks me to bring them!
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
The best chocolate chip cookies I have ever tasted.
undefined Member
Rating: 3 stars
I just made these. The texture is great (not chewy, but light and soft inside) and even though I like a little bit of salt with my sweet, next time I would cut it by half. Also, I had to increase the bake time by about 12 minutes. I used my ice cream scoop, which made for large cookies (closer to 30 than 24). A little too much dough per cookie. I'd recommend making more, smaller sized cookies. I used a w[filtered] 12 oz bag of semi-sweet chocolate chips, but I almost feel that it was a little too much for these cookies.
All-in-all the texture was nice, but they were just too large, and too salty and too sweet.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
This recipe works well. I made some alterations on it though. I used all semi-sweet chips. Never liked milk chocolate chips in chocolate chip cookies as it makes them a little too sweet. Cut out the half stick of butter (two is more than enough) and, like another reviewer, subbed the half cup of flour with cocoa powder. The most important step to making chocolate chip cookies is letting them chill. I let mine for about six hours. One hour's fine, but longer means they spread less.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I started with NY Times' recipe but now do this great recipe and refrigerate the batter for at least 24 hours per the Times' recipe. But all these recipes call for too much chocolate for my taste. All that chocolate overpowers the dough. Believe it or not, one cup of semisweet chips and one cup of chopped nuts does the trick. Still very chocolately. These get raves.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I have baked these cookies so many times I have lost count... have to be the most delicious cookies I have ever tasted! I follow the recipe almost exactly, but I sub one bag 60% dark chocolate chips for total chocolate called for. There is just something about the salty and sweet in this cookie that just makes it heaven in your mouth. I changed up the cooking time to 325* for 25-26 minutes and the texture is sublime! I will make these cookies forever since nothing else even comes close!
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These are my 'go to' chocolate chip cookies. I love the salty/sweet combination created by the coarse salt. I use a small cookie scoop and get four dozen cookies. I did have to decrease the baking time to 13-14 minutes. Everyone loves these!
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
Awesome !! I just cut out the salt amount. Place the bowl with all dough before placing it on the cookie pan. Used mi hands to place small balls of dough on cookie pan. Worked great. Absolutely great !
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
Awesome !! I just cut out the salt amount. Place the bowl with all dough before placing it on the cookie pan. Used mi hands to place small balls of dough on cookie pan. Worked great. Absolutely great !
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I agree with Bhanak completely...ABSOLUTELY DIVINE, after following the recipe exactly. Have no idea what Koo's problem could have been. I'm still baking and will have about 7 dozen when finished, using a small scoop. The cookies are plenty big enough. Will probably make half the recipe next time. Chilling the unbaked cookies keeps them from spreading out too much. Oh, and I added some chopped toasted pecans. Wonderful! They ARE the ultimate chocolate chip cookie.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These were great - just a little variation ... cut down on the amount of sale and refrigerate the dough BEFORE putting them on the cookie sheet, using a smaller scoop. The cookies do NOT spread out as in the picture - they stay more or less in a ball shape. Absolutely delicious!
undefined Member
Rating: 1 stars
What a waste of ingredients. Don't bother with theses. The result was a pile of mess that couldn't be saved.
undefined Member
Rating: 1 stars
What a waste of ingredients. Don't bother with theses. The result was a pile of mess that couldn't be saved.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These were great! But I found they were a little big so if you don't want them the size of the palm of your hand, I'd suggest making smaller balls of dough :P
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These cookies are very very delicious. I just made half the dough and got 30 cookies out of it which I baked for 14 minutes... perfect.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
the cookie was delicious, however it did yield a very flat salty/sweet taste. next time i will delete the baking powder and decrease the sugar and salt....
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These ARE the best chocolate chip cookies. The combination of the salt and two kind of chocolate chips is wonderful! I'm throwing out all my other recipes.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
Delicious! But if using regular (not course) salt, add no more than 1 1/2 tsp. I also lessened the minimum baking time by 1-2 minutes and got a very nice chewy outside and slightly softer inside of my cookies.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I'm wondering if those that found these too salty used regular salt instead of coarse salt? If using regular salt, you have to reduce it by half.
Otherwise, these are fabulous cookies. I can fit a double batch in my large stand mixer (barely). I make them and freeze them in our chest freezer just making a few cookies a week. They get rave reviews. I do, however, use milk chocolate for the chunks and semisweet for the chips.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I cut this recipe in half and add pecans. Perfect!
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These are the best chocolate chip cookie I ever had! One problem is that they are very flat. But every thing else is very good.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These are the best chocolate chip cookie I ever had! One problem is that they are very flat. But every thing else is very good.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
Instead of 3 1/2 cups flour, I used 3 cups flour and 1/2 cup Dutch process cocoa powder. I also used a combination of semi-sweet and dark chocolate chips, and Heath toffee bits. They were AMAZING. The salt works really well with the cocoa powder. I make cookies often and send them to work with my husband to share, and his co-workers thought these were the best I've ever made.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
Ultimate? No way. Below average, more like. I agree with peaches.... there was something missing from these cookies. (Although I didn't find them excessively buttery). I ended up throwing them out. Why waste the calories on a subpar cookie?
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I didn't care much for these, overall. They're a little grainy, the taste of the salt is noticeable, and they are REALLY buttery. I suppose if you really like buttery cookies that's a good thing, but I want the dough in my cookies to be less the center of attention than the chocolate.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
If Double Action Baking Powder is used, should the amount of baking powder in the recipe be reduced by half, ie. to half 1/8 tsp?
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
Oh we LOVED these cookies: big, crispy edges, chewy middle, plenty of chocolate, a little bit salty,... . I added some chopped macadamias, to put them over the edge. Next time, I'm going to add some walnuts.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These are by far the best CCC I have EVER had! Can't wait to take some to my Dad tomorrow. He is the CCC critic in the family and I know these will knock his socks off!
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I make CCC every week, and enjoy trying different recipes. I am always looking for the "ultimate" chocolate chip cookie recipe - one that satisfies everyone's tastes...this is one of the best! They are big, chewy, crunchy, the two chocolates add to the flavor - I didn't notice them being salty, but I usually under-measure salt.
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
these were too salty for my taste! just reduce the salt and they would be perfect. great consistency
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
I've made these cookies twice already and they are kicking my butt. It's all about that extra tsp of salt. Fantastic! Oh, and try adding chopped dried cherries, butterscotch chips and/or dark choc m
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
These have to be the best big chocolate chip cookie recipe I have made!
undefined Member
Rating: Unrated
This is a great base for Chocolate Chip-M