Way way too much baking powder. They're not supposed to be flat and crunchy, they should be a little puffy and soft!!

Love these cookies! They are a Christmas cookie staple in our house! They are definitely rich and chocolatey but that's just how we like them! They require a bit more work than a typical cookie and make a bit more mess, but it's all completely worth it! Love!

Chose to make these because the photo looked like cookies my grandmother used to make and I was feeling nostalgic. Sorry, grandma, but these were better! I didn't have any issues with the consistency of the dough. Yes, it is different than most other doughs, but if you follow the directions, it's fine. I use a bittersweet chocolate, so mine aren't really very sweet on the inside and that little bit of sugar on the outside is just enough to balance it. Mine bake at 350° for 10 minutes and come out perfectly pillowy. We like them best within an hour or two of coming out of the oven. A warm one is heavenly! So, I bake only one of the four divisions at a time, leaving the others in the fridge for a day or two until we're ready for more. Love these! They will be a family favorite for years to come.

Love these cookies! Easy to make, so delicious, chewy & addicting! Everyone loved them, the whole batch was gone in less than an hour! I didn't make logs, after a couple hours in the freezer I just quickly rolled them into balls and then rolled in powdered sugar. Logs maybe less messy but cleaning your hands only takes a minute and more fun for the kids!

I love these cookies. The easiest way to avoid the "sticky" situation is to chill the dough as directed, roll the balls in some regular granulated sugar, and THEN in powdered sugar. Voila! No stick, no mess. Absolutely a great cookie.

Batter resembles brownie batter not cookie dough!!! I didn't know that.. I kept adding fillers. This is definitely a level 2 baking (not as hard as a meringue, but not as easy as chocolate chip) and they are slightly time consuming. My first time... Little dry :), then read reviews, next time perfect! I have added mini chips, M&Ms and hazelnuts... All yummy!!

Really, really chocolatey. More than 2 of these would be chocolate overload. Not my favorite cookie; I'd much rather have a chocolate chip cookie. They are fairly difficult to make and I would think that they would be the best cookie ever for this much effort. They're pretty. I made my quartzite countertop cold by putting a lipped baking sheet with ice water on it for 15 or 20 min. Don't bother making logs - just cut off fairly even chunks and roll. Keep hands cold by dipping in ice water

I love this recipe! I've made it 4 times now. I always forget that the dough is not like cookie dough, but like brownie batter. Make sure you do chill it thoroughly before working with it. I freeze it because it stays cold longer so it doesn't melt in your hands. Dust your hands w/powdered sugar while you are rolling the balls. Instead of rolling into a log while chilling, I just press it flat in plastic, then cut 1x1" cubes before forming into balls. YUM! Consistent, and delicious!

I love this recipe! I've made it 4 times now. I always forget that the dough is not like cookie dough, but like brownie batter. Make sure you do chill it thoroughly before working with it. I freeze it because it stays cold longer so it doesn't melt in your hands. Dust your hands w/powdered sugar while you are rolling the balls. Instead of rolling into a log while chilling, I just press it flat in plastic, then cut 1x1" cubes before forming into balls. YUM! Consistent, and delicious!

I was working with this dough forming it into balls and getting very frustrated with the dough melting in my hands and making a big mess. I started to write a negative review to vent my frustration, when I realized that other reviewers liked these cookies! I went back to my dough and worked with it coming out of the freezer. After forming lumpy balls, I was able to form rounder balls after rolling them in sugar. I rechilled the dough balls before baking and the cookies came out nicely...