Create a masked-off shape with stencil tape on a glass.
Using a large brush, paint the glass with Martha Stewart Crafts Satin Paint in Marmalade. Let dry completely and paint another coat as necessary.
Next, using the large brush, paint a wide mouth with Martha Stewart Crafts Chalkboard Paint in Black. Let dry completely and paint another coat as necessary. Then, using a detail brush, paint eyes with Chalkboard Paint in Black. Let dry completely before proceeding to the next step.
Pour a little bit of Martha Stewart Crafts Erasable Liquid Chalk into a dish, and use a detail brush to paint eye and teeth details onto the chalkboard areas of the glass.
Once all paints are completely dry, carefully peel off stencil tape.
Repeat with remaining glasses, using other colors like black and gray Chalkboard paints, or Satin Paint in Sweet Potato.