Save to your Collections
Sorry for the inconvenience! Saving is temporarily unavailable as we work through a few kinks in our new recipe design (we hope you like it!). Don't worry, your collections are safe and you'll be able to save recipes again very soon.
Review this Recipe
Reviewing recipes is temporarily unavailable as we work through a few kinks in our new recipe design. You'll be able to comment again soon. Sorry for the inconvenience!
This is the best frosting recipe I have ever made! Not too sweet, but just sweet enough, smooth, and buttery. Fairly easy, but you definitely want a stand mixer. You just follow the directions exactly like they are written. I used the Wilton gel food coloring and did not notice any bad taste from it. You will literally want to eat it by the spoonful. It makes A LOT of frosting.
This my friends is the worlds best frosting.If you are looking for a bakery style cloyingly sweet frosting,this IS NOT IT! This frosting is sophisticated.It is silky smooth from the 2 pounds of butter and it just melts on your tongue. Yes it is sweet, but not TOO sweet. It is more time consuming than your average frosting, but well worth it. When I want to WOW someone with a cake, I always frost it with this frosting. FYI..I don't use food coloring w/this frosting, I think it adds a nasty flavor
Wonderful!! Best homemade frosting I've ever had! You're going to need a kitchen aide for this. Unless you have arms of steel, there is a LOT of mixing. YUMMY!
aaleves> re: runny b-cream...I wonder if you did what I did at first. I put in 2 sticks of butter (not 2 lbs!). Couldn't figure out what happened til I re-read. 4 CUPS(!!) of butter. yikes.
Add melted
Add melted
I liked Martha's Baking Handbook recipe, which is very similar but yields about 4 cups, and I halve even that. That recipe says bring the egg/sugar mixture to 160 degrees; add melted
I liked Martha's Baking Handbook recipe, which is very similar but yields about 4 cups, and I halve even that. That recipe says bring the egg/sugar mixture to 160 degrees; add melted
Should the butter be room temperature when adding it to the sugar/egg white mixture?
Delicious!!! Perfect consistency for decorating too.
"Striping the bag" is when you add random stripes of gel food color or different colored icing to the inside of your piping bag before filling it with the icing you are going to use. When you pipe out your icing it will have "stripes of the color you put on the inside of the bag. However, the "stripes" are not literally stripes. It depends on how you do it.
I'm curious...what does "Stripe your piping bag" mean?
This is SO clever and cute! Stripe your piping bag for added effects, and use any buttercream-based frosting you prefer. I've been looking for something "special" for Halloween treats, and these are perfect -- taste great with the "ugh" and "oh, yuck" effect that kids love!
I have used this type of recipe before - just smaller amounts and without the butter. you can half the recipe or even smaller if you want. Then it may not seem so overwhelming to make. remember that the egg whites expand when beaten so the volume of the raw ingredients will be much less than the finished ingredient.
Excellent - and tastes like marshmallows:)
i have to say that buttercream is the toughest frosting to make!
i hope this works, 2 pounds of butter and 10 egg whites are kinda spendy.
I'd go with basic buttercream icing that does NOT use butter at all. It uses shortening (I know, using butter creates a more solid taste...but, adding butter flavor to the shortening is ok). It is stiff and it contains meringue powder, wich allows the icing to dry with a subtle crust (like a wedding cake)...thus, IDEAL for flowers and roses. Btw, using a hand mixer to make this, is possible, but incredibly difficult. They do have ready made "decorator" icing at craft stores.
Can you make this recipe a chocolote buttercream?
I don't have hand mixer,if I whisk by hand...it's will take more than 10 minutes..
will be possible?
Has anyone had any problems with it being runny? i only have a hand mixer, could this affect the outcome? i am trying to make icing flowers with it and their is no way they will keep shape. i am new at all of this... please help with any suggestions. Thanks!
carmenid, it's regular sugar... you want to put the sugar with the egg whites in the bowl of your electric mixer and whisk over top of simmering water. It dissolves... took me longer than 3 minutes for the mixture to get warm, but when it does and is smooth... it's totally ready! and it's absolutely delicious
is this regular sugar or confectioners sugar?
This is my favorite frosting. I can't imagine using 9 cups of it on just 28 cupcakes, though. I generously frosted 36 and only used about half of the 9 cups.