Save to your Collections
Sorry for the inconvenience! Saving is temporarily unavailable as we work through a few kinks in our new recipe design (we hope you like it!). Don't worry, your collections are safe and you'll be able to save recipes again very soon.
Review this Recipe
Reviewing recipes is temporarily unavailable as we work through a few kinks in our new recipe design. You'll be able to comment again soon. Sorry for the inconvenience!
I wanted to make some changes to my last comment. I should of followed the recipe. Less filling is better. I put too much and they weren't as dry as I would have liked.
Also, make sure you get jam that has less sugar. A great brand is E.D. Smith that I got at Costco. It has more fruit & 1/2 the sugar that regular preserves have. They make all kinds. I used the Cherry and it was fantastic and I used some off brand for the strawberry which was tooooo sweet.
ED Smith also makes a rhubarb.
Excellent recipe. I made it half strawberry jam and the other half cherry jam (my son does not like cherry). You definately need more that one cup of jam....need 2 cups plus for the 9X13 baking dish--this way you have more of a filling. They turned out beautiful and the shortbread cookie on the top and bottom was wonderful. Just had one with my morning cup of tea.
Does this really qualify as a shortbread if the recipe calls for egg yolks? This may be more of a bar cookie.
Responding to BKGWIN's email....
I substitute Splenda for sugar. 1 c sugar = 1 c Splenda
I also use half the amount of butter and sustitute the half with apple sauce.
Happy baking !
Gluten-Free Flour Mixes - I found this website that has a bunch of gluten-free mixes that you can use and substitute for wheat flour 1:1 ratio. You might have to experiment since the gluten in wheat is critical to some recipes, but I noticed that some mixes have a binder, of sorts, in them. Good luck! http://www.csaceliacs.org/recipes/FlourFormulas.php
I didn't bother with the vanilla bean since I didn't have one on hand so I just used 1t vanilla extract. A good source for vanilla beans and all sorts of spices is Penzeys. They have stores, but I use their mail-order since none are close to me.
To the comment about the high-carb count. This recipe isn't exactly on the healthy list. I say enjoy it as it is in moderation or don't bother.
Agree with cookieace, shortbread is all about the butter! Perfect combo of butter and sugar.
Does anyone know how many cups 1 pound rhubarb is?
Can an alternative sweetner be used? The recipe has a lot of carbs! Can you show a breakdown of nutrition and caloric values? I have to watch my calorie intake as well as salt and fat content.
how to convert this too glutin free - is a recipe for glutin free shortbread using rice and arrowroot flour - then grate it as per normal shortbread - will this subsitute just as easily???
I found vanilla beans at my local grocery store, in the spices section, for $22 each. Then I found them on-line a Beanilla at: http://www.beanilla.com/index.php
I paid only $3.45 for 3 vanilla beans, plus shipping! I've ordered vanilla beans from them ever since.:
Where do you find a vanilla bean? Or can you substitute vanilla extract?
Baking with Julie? Julie Child - think you should correct the information to read Julia!
Shortbread IS a butter delivery vehicle. Yummmm!
Is the one pound of butter is type o? This seems extremely high.