Save to your Collections
Sorry for the inconvenience! Saving is temporarily unavailable as we work through a few kinks in our new recipe design (we hope you like it!). Don't worry, your collections are safe and you'll be able to save recipes again very soon.
Review this Recipe
Reviewing recipes is temporarily unavailable as we work through a few kinks in our new recipe design. You'll be able to comment again soon. Sorry for the inconvenience!
Be sure to read: 1 1/2 tsp COARSE salt - this is considerably less salt than the same amount of fine (or table) salt! I'd also suggest using rehydrated dried cranberries, or doing a very quick simmer of fresh berries in a small amount of simple syrup - just until they pop. Drain the berries and use in the pie, and reserve the cranberry syrup for pancakes!
I should have read the comments! yes, the cranberries are TOO TART, and i only used 12 oz! i am a cranberry fan, but i think these should be treated first, And YES, 1 1/2 tsp salt is too much! i also wonder if this recipe was tested, or if there is a step missing, or what. disappointing!
I made this pie for Thanksgiving but it was way too tart. I think I should have used dried cranberries instead. Also, I should have known that a one teaspoon of salt is too much for a pie this size. This pie was so salty and so tart that we ended up throwing it away. Very disappointing.
I made the filling according to the recipe, but instead of a lattice top, sprinkled on a streusel top. It complemented the cranberries well; my guests just loved it.
The pie was a great hit at Thanksgiving! I added 2 granny smith apples
I used four pounds of pears and fourteen ounces of cranberries, and I still found the pie to be quite tart, although not unpleasantly so. However, I do think that the recipe calls for too much salt: 1/2 - 3/4 of a teaspoon would be sufficient. I keep detecting hints of saltiness in the pie, which is rather disappointing. I think some ice cream will mitigate this problem.
This pie was wonderful. Directions were perfect. The pears need to be really ripe and juicy. Even the kids loved it. I did serve it warm with a caramel based ice cream and and a drizzle of caramel honey butter
I made this pie for Thanksgiving and I've really messed up with cranberries before so I upped the pears and lowered the cranberries because I know their tartness can overpower. My pie pan wasn't a deep dish like this recipe calls for so I cut the filling recipe in half. I used 4 large pears and about 9 oz of fresh cranberries, which is a little less than a bag of the Ocean Spray brand. I added a little more sugar and some cinnamon, nutmeg
This pie looked fantastic, although I made a real lattice crust, but it was so tart I didn't think it was edible. My dinner guests did eat it but were probably just being polite while choking it down! Was this recipe tested before publishing it?
My crust came out great, however the cranberries were still too tart (sour). I used fresh cranberries (Ocean Spray). Has anyone else made this pie, and if you have - is there any advice? Should I use more sugar?