No Thanks
Keep In Touch With

Sign up and we'll send inspiration straight to you.

Martha Stewart takes your privacy seriously. To learn more, please read our Privacy Policy.

How to Cook Fish 101

Martha Stewart Living, April/May 1993

Judging Freshness
All great fish dishes begin with a piece of good-quality fish, which can be purchased either fresh or frozen. "Frozen," it should be noted, does not mean that the fish is not fresh. In fact, much of the fish we buy has been frozen at some point, whether it’s found in the freezer section or displayed on ice at the fish market.

For fillets, the best way to determine freshness is by smell. A fillet should be virtually odorless; a fishy smell indicates that a large number of bacteria have already developed. It should also be free of bones, bits of skin, and blood (not necessarily a sign of freshness, but of a good fishmonger), and should not curl at the edges or show signs of yellowing.

Determining the freshness of a whole fish is slightly easier. Again, the fish should not give off an odor, and its eyes should be clear, not cloudy. The skin should be shiny and adhere tightly to the flesh.

Storing Fish
After purchasing, rewrap fresh fillets tightly in plastic, and place them in the coldest part of the refrigerator, preferably on ice; cook them as soon as possible. Defrost frozen fish overnight in the coldest part of the refrigerator (a thick fillet or whole fish may take up to two days to defrost). Slow, cold defrosting discourages "drip loss," so the cooked fish will be moist and the texture firm, but not tough.


Comments (2)

  • ShannonJefferies 31 Dec, 2011

    PS: My new comment is about your website. After posting my last comment, I discovered an error in my typing. I just posted the comment two seconds ago, but I'm not allowed to edit it. I've never been to a site that didn't allow you to edit or update what you post. So far, I'm disappointed in this website and it's articles. I expected higher standards from Martha Stewart.

  • ShannonJefferies 31 Dec, 2011

    The title of this article is "How to Cook Fish". It explains how to buy and store fish, absolutely nothing about cooking it!